Although it won the Academy Award for Best Picture in 1960 (the last completely black and white film to win), and sits at #80 on the American Film Instituteâ€™s list of the top 100 American films of all-time, I get the impression that itâ€™s not nearly as well-known as the vast majority of the other films on the list.
The plot concerns C.C. Baxter (Lemmon), a young number cruncher at a big insurance company. A dedicated career man, he has lately taken to lending the use of his apartment to managers and executives in need of a safe place for extramarital trysts. Although it can make his life a bit hectic, he takes it all in stride, confident that the venture will help him rise in the ranks quickly, which will then aid him in gaining the affection of Fran Kubelik (MacLaine), a sunny elevator operator heâ€™s had his eye on for a while.
When the CEO, Jeff Sheldrake (Fred MacMurray) finds out what he has going on, Baxter gets called into a meeting. After a stern monologue from Sheldrake, it eventually surfaces that Sheldrake does not want to fire Baxter, but rather promote him, and have broad access to the apartment. Baxter agrees, unaware that Sheldrakeâ€™s mistress is in fact Miss Kubelik.
When Baxter discovers this, the movie shifts. Sheldrake confides in Baxter that not only does he really not care for Miss Kubelik very much, but that he has a long history of affairs, and in each case he strings the woman along, making her think he intends to leave his family for her, never really intending to do such a thing. Then on Christmas Eve, without knowing that his secretary alerted Fran to his philandering history, Sheldrake gives her a story about how itâ€™ll be a while before he can leave his family for her. She starts to see through his lies, and, tearing up, states matter-of-factly, â€œYou think I wouldâ€™ve learned by now. When youâ€™re in love with a married man, you shouldnâ€™t wear mascara.â€ He gives her $100 as a Christmas present, and leaves. Baxter comes home to find her passed out on the bed, having taken a bottle of sleeping pills.
When I first saw The Apartment, I couldnâ€™t believe that a movie like this would have been made in America at that time. Europe had already seen groundbreaking films like The 400 Blows and Breathless, but Hollywood was still working under the old Production Code, which made frank discussion of adult issues a difficult matter. The Graduate was still 7 years away, and although The Apartment is generally considered a comedy, Wilder doesnâ€™t pull any punches when dealing with the big real-world issues of suicide and infidelity. This is no slapstick. If anything, the melancholic but still comedic tone reminds me of Harold and Maude or Rushmore.For the first half, Baxter is content to facilitate the sin of others, just as long as he can benefit from it. When he finds Fran passed out in his apartment, he has to face the harsh reality of sin. The Bible tells us that sin leads to death (Romans 6:23), but it also tells us that God gives grace, and sometimes that comes in the form of a difficult wake-up call. Baxter doesnâ€™t want Fran to be mistreated because he has a crush on her, but heâ€™s been willing to let scores of other girls be mistreated by the married men who are using them. When the doctor next door helps him save Fran, he tells Baxter, â€œLive now, pay later â€“ dinerâ€™s club! You need to grow up, Baxter, be a mensch. Do you know what that is? A mensch, a human being!â€
Thatâ€™s good advice, but not good enough. Yes, Baxter needs to â€œman upâ€, but as Christians, we know that itâ€™s being human that gets us in trouble in the first place. As humans, we are incapable of the perfection Christ calls us to in Matthew 5:48. â€œIâ€™m so fouled up,â€ Fran tells Baxter. Sheâ€™s also halfway there. Weâ€™re all fouled up, but Jesus isnâ€™t, he loves us regardless, and by his grace we are forgiven. As we see in Baxterâ€™s transformation, itâ€™s never too late to grow up, take our sin seriously, and turn from it. The important thing is who you turn to. Donâ€™t settle for being a mensch.